PDA

View Full Version : Prelude 2 i7



MoonGear
05-13-2009, 06:44 PM
I ordered a Prelude 2 near the end of March and received it on April 22.

Specs

Exterior Finish: Black Brushed Aluminum Finish
Power Supply: 750W Silverstone Strider Power Supply
Graphics Accelerator: NVIDIA® GeForceT GTX 260 896MB GDDR3 w/ PhysX
Motherboard: Asus P6T Intel X58 Chipset
Processor: Intel® CoreT i7-965 Extreme Edition 3.2GHz
Processor Cooling: Zalman Ultra Quiet CNPS9500 AT 92mm CPU Cooler w/ Copper Base
Memory: 12GB Triple Channel DDR3 1333MHz
MAINGEAR Redline Service: Yes, Redline my system!
Hard Drive One: Western Digital Caviar Black 750GB 7200 RPM 32MB Cache - SATA II
Hard Drive Two: Western Digital Caviar Black 1TB 7200 RPM 32MB Cache - SATA II
Hard Drive Three: Western Digital Caviar Black 1TB 7200 RPM 32MB Cache - SATA II
RAID: RAID 1 - Data Redundancy and Protection
Memory Card Reader: All-in-One Internal USB 2.0 Flash Card Reader & Writer
Optical Drive One: 22X Dual Layer DVD±RW Drive w/ LightScribe Technology
Optical Drive Two: Lite-On Blu-ray Optical Player
Sound: Sound Blaster X-Fi Titanium Fatal1ty Professional Series
Network Card: Onboard Dual Marvell 88E8056 Gigabit Controller
Productivity Software: Microsoft Office 2007 Professional
Security Software: Free Antivirus Software
Operating System: Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium (64-Bit) SP1
The Final Finesse: Flawless Hand-crafted Wiring and Cable Management
Warranty: 14 Month Standard Maingear Warranty

Notes

The GeForce GTX 260 is the Core 216 version, and is manufactured by EVGA. As I understand it, it's factory overclocked. I know for certain that it's way more card than I need right now, so whether it's OC'd or not is probably a moot point.

I didn't want to go nuts on the CPU overclocking because, when it comes right down to it, the stock 965 processor is more than fast enough for me. I also don't want to burn any more electricity than necessary. Rafael, who first called me about my order, suggested that Maingear could bump up the speed as much as possible without raising the voltage, and I readily agreed. Gus, who built my system, got 3.38 GHz out of the CPU under that restriction. So I wouldn't call this thing "redlined," but it does "rev" a bit more enthusiastically.

I got the Zalman CPU cooler just in case the extra cooling might make a difference. And because it looks cool when I have the case open. :D

RAM prices are too low not to go with 12 GB of it. I won't have to worry about having to install more, as I did with my Voodoo. Photoshop loves me now.

The 750GB drive contains the OS and apps. The two 1TB HDs are in a RAID 1 configuration so my laziness in doing full data backups doesn't bite me in the future.

Praise

The case looks great on my all-black AnthroCart table. They look like they were made for each other. The blue lighting in the front grille, which matches the power-on light, is a nice touch. I love this particular shade of blue.

The etching is very nice indeed, and I'm glad I found something to put on the case that I can call my own. (But do see the note below under "Quibbles.")

This thing is quiet. I can hear the front fan, but it's no worse than having a room fan going, and much quieter than my old Voodoo PC. (I can hear the Voodoo over the small TV I have here in Command Central; the TV drowns out the Prelude.) It will probably get louder when I make it work harder, but in my normal operating mode it's a terrific improvement.

Gus did a great job on the cabling. It really is as nice as advertised. I'm afraid to touch anything in there. :D

Quibbles

The DVD drive (an LG unit) does not fit into its opening very well at all. There's about a 1 MM gap all around it. It wouldn't be too noticable except for the fact that the power-on light leaks through the gap. I'm not sure what, if anything, I'm going to do about it, but "ignore it" would be a good guess.

My custom etched graphic fades a little bit toward the back of the case. I can't tell if that's intentional or not, especially since the MAINGEAR lettering on the same panel fades a bit toward the front. But nobody, including me, can tell the custom bit is faded by looking at it in its natural habitat since the area in question is in relative darkness. The bottom line is, it doesn't bother me enough to ask about it. I am mentioning it in case it makes a difference to anyone out there considering having their own graphic etched on.

Try as I might, I cannot find but one Ethernet port. I'm guessing that line is a carryover from the previous Prelude. It is a Gigabit port, though, which has made for a tremendous increase in throughput to my NAS.

When hibernating, the power light on the case blinks at a fairly high rate, and it's pretty bright. At night, it looks like someone is outside my window with a turn signal on. I wish I had some way of having it light briefly at much longer intervals.

None of these things really counts as a negative. I'm not even concerned enough about them to call Maingear about them; I've got more important things to get riled about.

Finally...

When seeking a builder for my new PC, I ran trial orders through a number of the "boutique" builders, as well as Dell. I didn't check out Maingear at first, because I had never heard of them.

I would have considered another Voodoo, but the current HP/Voodoo offering, the Firebird, while gorgeous, is merely a mid-level PC, and those get obsolete way too soon. But a blog from Rahul Sood (top guy at Voodoo and now CTO at HP) about the Firebird mentioned a conversation he had with Wallace Santos, and Sood had high praise for Maingear. So I checked it out, and I'm very glad I did. (I suspect HP will be less pleased if they find out.)

As it turns out, I could not get nearly as much machine for my money anywhere else than I have by buying this Prelude from Maingear. With shipping included, I paid less than $4K for this computer. I don't remember finding anything else for less than $4500 w/o shipping, and even then I would have gotten much less in terms of equipment and performance than what's sitting on my desk right now. That fact, and MG's stellar reputation, got me to finally buy the new PC I'd been promising myself for two years.

So far, so good. Color me happy!

ChrisMorley
05-13-2009, 07:09 PM
Thank you so much for your detailed review! Would you mind sharing it with others at http://www.resellerratings.com/store/Maingear_Computers ? We'd greatly appreciate it!

MoonGear
05-21-2009, 07:15 PM
Thank you so much for your detailed review! Would you mind sharing it with others at http://www.resellerratings.com/store/Maingear_Computers ? We'd greatly appreciate it!

Done, word for word (under user name MoonDarter so people won't accuse me of being a Maingear shill).

It hasn't shown up yet as of this writing. Maybe the account activation process takes some time.

ChrisMorley
05-21-2009, 08:37 PM
Yup from what I understand it takes a while to show up. We just signed up for their merchant services so I got an email stating your review is pending. Thank you so much, it really means a lot to us when our customers are willing to share their experience.

dante57
05-21-2009, 09:16 PM
Great rig and nice review! Glad you found MG, my pre-buy shopping experience was very similar to yours. I didn't spend quite as much as you, but I know I got more for my money with MG than I would have gotten most anywhere else. I'd like to know what your main uses are gonna be? Have you put it through its paces yet?

MoonGear
05-24-2009, 10:28 PM
Great rig and nice review! Glad you found MG, my pre-buy shopping experience was very similar to yours. I didn't spend quite as much as you, but I know I got more for my money with MG than I would have gotten most anywhere else. I'd like to know what your main uses are gonna be? Have you put it through its paces yet?

I work a lot with Microsoft Word and Excel at work, and try to teach myself as much as I can about using VBA for both apps in my spare time. This makes me look smart at the office.

Aside from that, I'm pretty much a hobbyist. If something looks fun, I'll try it.

I'm programming with Visual Studio, in Visual Basic. Seeing as practically all my programming experience is with VBA, I'm still trying to get the hang of OOP. I'm getting there, slowly but... well... slowly. But, speaking of "slow," if I write something and it takes forever to run, it's now obviously my fault.

I use Photoshop quite a bit, and would like to learn more about Illustrator. PS starts in about five seconds on the Prelude, and is so much faster overall that I'm actually amazed. I'm not easily amazed.

I'm having a lot of fun with SketchUp. That has also become much easier to work with on the new machine. I may try other 3D apps later on.

I'll be installing SoundForge soon. I'll be re-ripping my CDs to the Prelude. (The music files on my old PC are in Sony's format, and since I've finally conceded that MiniDisc is dead, I'll be deleting those and ripping in MP3 format.) The good news is that I can use SoundForge to edit some tracks to a greater degree than I could with Sony Connect, and can normalize the tracks so I don't blow my brains out when a low-volume track is followed by a high-volume one.

I'm also going to make my own ringtones and figure out how to get then into my new phone. With all the CDs I have, I'll be darned if I'm going to pay for ringtones.

I'll be watching DVDs and Blu-ray discs on occasion. I like to use screencaps to make wallpapers. Blu-ray screencaps could be very interesting.

I play games, but I'm hardly hard-core about it. I'll be installing Civilization 4 once I feel at home with this system; my old PC didn't have enough grunt to run it. I'll try to install Civ3 Complete as well, although that may have compatibility problems. I'll also be playing SimCity 4. I'm not into first-person shooters much, so I probably won't really work the GTX 260 GPU anytime soon. I got it mainly to have graphics power in reserve.

In the future: Who knows? But at least now I've a PC that will likely handle anything I install for some time to come.

golfman560
05-24-2009, 11:04 PM
I'll try to install Civ3 Complete as well, although that may have compatibility problems.

It doesn't get many problems, I think the only thing you'll have a problem with is the online getting disconnected every once in awhile.

And what you do sounds like what I do but I don't really have time to do any of it anymore.

MoonGear
05-27-2009, 12:09 AM
It doesn't get many problems, I think the only thing you'll have a problem with is the online getting disconnected every once in awhile.

And what you do sounds like what I do but I don't really have time to do any of it anymore.

I don't have time for all this either, which is why I sleep 4-5 hours a night five days a week. :D

RottynDawg
05-27-2009, 12:07 PM
Awesome review Moon. I enjoyed reading about the selection process and the reasons for going with Maingear.

MoonGear
06-02-2009, 08:19 PM
I've been using Photoshop quite a bit in the past few days. An internal fan sometimes winds up for a moment or two as I apply several adjustments to an image. The effect is as though the computer is breathing. It's not terribly louder than the normal fan noise, and still way quieter than my Voodoo.

I'm just guessing, but I think it's the Zalman cooler. I don't think the GPU is getting enough work yet to work up a digital sweat.

I also found out that my review posted on ResellerReviews was rejected for violations of their TOS. I wasn't given specifics, but it may be my mentions of other manufacturers (like Dell and HP), and possibly naming the internal component makers. I've edited and resubmitted the review.

Speaking of ResellerReviews, if you post a review and use IE8, you won't be able to sign in and edit your review unless you run IE8 in its Compatibility View mode.

MoonGear
06-12-2009, 12:30 PM
My review finally showed up at ResellerRatings. I'm happy to add to the high praise for Maingear. They certainly deserve it!